Sammy's City Island Menu

See our mouth-watering food & martini wine menus. Traditional, seafood & vegetarian cuisine, plus kids menu – something for everyone.

If you would like to make a table reservation for lunch, or dinner here at Sammy’s Fish Box, then please click the button below. Lunch and Dinner is served from our A la Carte menu.

Please let your server know about any food allergies, special request or a special celebration before ordering. 

Sammy’s Fried Specialties

Jumbo Shrimp Combinations

Surf & Turf at Sammy’s

Sammy’s Fish Market

Our Fabulous Feasts for 2

Italian Specialties

Sammy’s Chef Specials

For Steak Lovers

Sammy’s Chowders

Sammy’s Luncheon Menu

Sandwich Platters

Sammy’s Salads

Children’s Menu


Sammy’s Famous Complimentary offerings.

Every table receives two home baked breads, one being our famous white Crusty Mountain Bread and the other our one of a kind Cornbread served
with a wedge of delicious cheese and iced relish tray. Every dinner comes with our special Garden Salad, a choice of dressing as well as Spanish
Rice, sweet corn and your choice of French fries, fried sweet potato, tostones, baked potato or linguine in white or red sauce.


Interested in downloading the menu?

Acrobat is available for both Mac and Windows. Click the button below to download Adobe Acrobat Reader.

If you are unable to download or read the menu, please call the restaurant.